How we evaluate
Seven criteria. One score.
The editors score every criterion from 1 to 10. Two of the seven are measured rather than argued; the other five are signed judgement. The Overall UXE Score is their weighted mean — and it is published in full on the project's profile.
- criteria, equally weighted
- 07
- scored in half points
- 1–10
- criteria measured, not argued
- 02
- the bar for recognition
- 7.0
01/The criteria
What we ask of a product.
01
Usability
Can people complete what they came to do — efficiently, confidently and without error?
What we look for
Whether a first-time user finishes the main task without help, without backtracking and without dread.
What to show them
The two or three tasks that matter most, and any completion or error-rate data you have.
02
Information Architecture
Is content organized, labeled and navigable in the way people actually think?
What we look for
Labels people would use themselves, a hierarchy that matches how they think, and a way back from anywhere.
What to show them
Navigation at every level, search and empty states — not only the happy path.
03
UI & Consistency
Is the visual language coherent and purposeful across every screen and state?
What we look for
One visual language, applied with judgement: type, spacing, colour and components that behave alike.
What to show them
Several screens from different corners of the product, plus any design-system documentation.
04
Interaction & Feedback
Does every action respond clearly, promptly and meaningfully?
What we look for
Every action answered — immediately, proportionately, and in a way that says what happened.
What to show them
Loading, saving, failing and undoing. A short screen recording says more than a still.
05
Performance
Does it feel fast — perceived and measured — on real devices and networks?
What we look for
Speed as people feel it, on the devices and networks they actually have.
What to show them
Field data if you have it (Core Web Vitals, cold-start times), and what you did to earn it.
06
Accessibility
Can everyone use it, including people relying on assistive technology?
What we look for
Keyboard, screen reader, contrast, motion and language — a product usable without your eyes or your mouse.
What to show them
Your conformance claim and accessibility statement. An honest 'partial' beats an unverifiable 'full'.
07
Learnability
How quickly does a first-time user become a confident one?
What we look for
How quickly a new user becomes a confident one — and whether the product teaches without lecturing.
What to show them
Onboarding, first-run states, and anything you changed after watching people struggle.
The seven weights are equal today. They live in one file so they can be rebalanced between seasons without touching a single page — and any change is announced before the season it applies to.
02/The scale
What a number means.
9.0 – 10
Exceptional
Sets the reference for its category. Rare, and never given for polish alone.
8.0 – 8.9
Excellent
Consistently strong across the board, with real depth in its focus criteria.
7.0 – 7.9
Accomplished
Meets the UXE standard. Clear intent, few rough edges.
5.0 – 6.9
Competent
Works, but unremarkable — or strong in places and weak in others.
1.0 – 4.9
Below standard
Fails the people it is for in ways the team could have caught.
Where the thresholds sit
- Editors’ Choice≥ 8.5
- Official Selection≥ 8.0
- Featured≥ 7.0
- Distinction in one criterion≥ 9.0
- Grand Prix≥ 9.0
- Winner≥ 8.0
- Honorable Mention≥ 7.5
- Nominee≥ 7.0
Every threshold is a floor, never a guarantee. The editors may always confer less — or nothing at all.
03/Category focus
Each category weighs its own.
All seven criteria are scored in every category. What changes is where we look hardest — a design system is not judged the way a checkout is.
- Product Experience
Weighs Usability, IA, Learnability most closely.
- Mobile Experience
Weighs Interaction, Performance, Usability most closely.
- Web Experience
Weighs IA, Performance, A11y most closely.
- E-commerce Experience
Weighs Usability, UI, Interaction most closely.
- Service Experience
Weighs Usability, IA, A11y most closely.
- Interaction Design
Weighs Interaction, Learnability, Performance most closely.
- Inclusive & Ethical Design
Weighs A11y, Usability, Learnability most closely.
- UX Writing & Content Design
Weighs IA, Learnability, Usability most closely.
- Design Systems
Weighs UI, A11y, Performance most closely.
- UX Research & Strategy
Weighs Usability, IA, Learnability most closely.
- AI & Emerging Experience
Weighs Interaction, Learnability, A11y most closely.
- Innovation in UX
Weighs Interaction, Usability, Learnability most closely.
04/Limits
What a score isn’t.
Not a popularity contest
No public vote, no share count, no follower threshold. A score comes from using the product, and two of the seven come from measuring it.
Not a business verdict
We score the experience, not the revenue, the funding or the market. A beloved product can still be hard to use.
Not for sale
Entering is free and judging finishes before money is ever mentioned. No payment, package or plan moves a number.
Enter
Ready to be measured?
Enter a live product or a public beta in up to three categories. Submitting is free, and the editors score it against these seven criteria.