Editorial standards
Independence, written down.
An award is worth exactly as much as the distance between its judging and its invoicing. Here is ours, in detail, so you can hold us to it.
01/Independence
Six commitments.
01
Judging happens before money
An entry is reviewed and a decision is recorded before any payment link exists. The editors who score and confer have no commercial target to hit, and no sight of who has paid for anything. The sequence is enforced by the system itself: a payment link can only be attached to a submission that has already been recognized.02
Advertising buys space, never judgement
Sponsors and advertisers get placements that are labelled as such. They do not get a say in what is recognized, an early look at results, or a hint about who is nominated. An advertiser’s own work is judged like anybody else’s, against the same seven criteria and the same published thresholds.03
Conflicts are declared and reassigned
An editor who worked on a product, works for the company behind it, or is pitching for its business does not assess it. It goes to a different editor, and the recusal is recorded against the entry.04
The scores are the reasoning
Every published profile carries the full breakdown: all seven criteria, the weighted mean, the conditions the two measured criteria were taken under, and the verdict that was written from them. If our reasoning is wrong, it is wrong in public and can be argued with.05
Results stay embargoed
Award results are sealed until the announcement date — from winners, sponsors, press and partners alike. A result that leaks early is a favour to somebody, and favours are how awards lose their meaning.06
Recognition can be withdrawn
If an entry turns out to have misrepresented the work — invented metrics, borrowed screens, an accessibility claim the product doesn’t meet — the honor is revoked, the profile comes down and the badge stops resolving. We say what happened on the profile’s page rather than quietly deleting it.
02/Corrections
When we get it wrong.
Factual errors
A wrong name, a wrong credit, a wrong link: tell us and we fix it the same day, and note the change on the profile if it was material.
Process errors
If a decision rested on the wrong version of a product, or on a page that was down when we looked, we re-assess it from scratch. That has a cost; we absorb it.
Judgement
A score you disagree with is not an error. Scores aren't reopened because a maker is unhappy — that's what publishing them in full, with their conditions, is for.
03/How work gets here
Chosen, then opened.
Chosen by the editors
Every profile on the site today belongs to work nobody submitted. The editors picked the product, used it, measured it under conditions printed next to the numbers, and scored it themselves against the same seven criteria. None of it was entered, none of it was paid for, and none of it competes in the quarterly awards — those are for entered work only.
What that means for a score
There is no outside panel, and the site does not claim one. A verdict here is signed by the editors and nobody else, and no score is attributed to a name that did not produce it. If a panel is ever seated it will be named, and its scores will appear on the profiles it judges — until then, this is the whole of who judged what you are reading.
Two of the seven criteria are not argued. Performance and accessibility come from fixed bands applied to measurements taken under the conditions printed beside them — largest contentful paint, layout shift and transfer size for one; the count and impact of automated violations for the other. The same bands are applied to every product, so those two scores can be checked rather than debated. The other five are the editors’ judgement, and they are signed.
Nothing on them is invented. Where only a product’s own team could tell us something — how they researched it, who worked on it, what it conforms to — the profile leaves it out rather than guessing, and links the public sources it was built from instead. If you made something we have assessed and want it corrected or removed, tell us and we will act on it.
04/What we publish
And what we never do.
Always published
- Every criterion score, and the weighted overall
- The conditions behind the two measured criteria
- The verdict the editors wrote, in full, signed
- The season, the categories and the result in each
Never published
- Declined entries — there is no list of rejected work, ever
- Contact details, or anything that identifies who submitted an entry
- What anyone paid, or which package they took
- Anything at all until the entrant activates the profile
The mechanics behind all of this — thresholds, limits, the order of events — are documented in the programme and the rules. If you think we’ve broken one of these commitments, we’d rather hear it than not: write to us.
Independence
Judged on the work. Only the work.
Free to enter, scored against seven published criteria, published in full. That's the whole proposition.